Williamsburg Family of Schools Blog

Online School Teachers: 6 Mentor Practices | Williamsburg

Written by A. Hailstone | Nov 17, 2026

 

What Makes Online School Teachers Great?

Think back to your favorite teachers in middle school and high school. It probably wasn’t their worksheets or even the course content that stuck with you the most. They’re likely your favorites because they showed real care for you, appreciated what you felt and thought, and/or saw something in you before you did. When families consider online school, the real question is often: will my student have teachers like that?

The best online school teachers do exactly that. At the Williamsburg Family of Schools, we hire, train, promote, and sometimes let go teachers, whom we call mentors, based on their ability to connect with students in this way.

We train them to do so through our Six Mentor Practices. Each one has a clear purpose, and together they create a learning experience where students participate, grow, feel known, and valued.

Here's what each practice means, what it looks like in class, and what it can mean for your student.

(The student moments below are paraphrased from our student stories. We share grade levels only to protect each student's privacy.)

 

1. Connection

Mentors make personal connections with students, and those connections inspire students to do great work. Research supports this: the American Psychological Association notes that students who feel connected to their teachers tend to trust them more, engage more in learning, and achieve at higher levels.

In practice, that means mentors learn each student's interests, notice when someone's been quiet, and hold office hours so students have a set time to ask for help one-on-one. Every class a student takes has its own mentor, so your student has several adults who know them.

One ninth grader shared that math used to mean hours of stress. Over the year, it became the class they looked forward to most. Nothing about math got easier. What changed was that they felt safe enough to ask the questions they'd been afraid to ask, and the understanding followed.

 

2. Engaging Presentation

Mentors use powerful stories, visuals, questions, and more to engage students in class. A history lesson might open with a single dramatic moment from the past. A scientific concept might start with an image that prompts students to ask, "Wait, how does that work?"
This matters even more in a live online class. When students are drawn into the material from the start, they come to the discussion with something to say, and the class has energy that carries through to the projects and writing that follow.

3. The Socratic Method

Mentors ask thought-provoking questions that help students reach their own conclusions. Instead of handing over the answer, they ask the next question: "What would the author say to that?" or "What's the strongest argument against your view?"

Students learn to consider an idea from multiple perspectives, support their views with evidence, and change their minds when the evidence calls for it. It's the heart of how we teach students how to think, not what to think.

It can also lead to discoveries students didn't expect. During a leadership discussion, one tenth grader shared a thought about how people respond when they feel out of control, then realized many classmates felt the same way. The insight was the student's own. The question simply gave it room to be said out loud.

 

4. Quality Feedback

Mentors give specific, meaningful feedback that helps students grow. Research from the Education Endowment Foundation finds that high-quality feedback is one of the most effective ways to improve learning, especially when it provides students with specific guidance on how to improve.

So our mentors aim past "good job" or "needs work." A mentor might write, "Your thesis is clear. Your second paragraph would be stronger with one example from the reading." Students know exactly what to do next, and mentors point out what's working too, so students learn to recognize their own progress.

 

5. Data-Driven Instruction

Mentors analyze learning data to personalize instruction and support every student's success. They pay attention to how each student is progressing over time, so small struggles get noticed early, and a student who's ready for more gets a new challenge.

When something shifts, a mentor might reach out for a check-in, explain a concept a different way, or adjust support. The data is never the point on its own. It's one more way mentors make sure every student is seen and growing.

 

6. Transformational Learning

Mentors create learning experiences that expand how students see themselves and the world. Through deep readings, lively discussions, and meaningful projects, students don't just learn material—they reflect on what it means for how they live, lead, and relate to others.

A twelfth grader found this while working on a relationships project in our Social Leadership class (which most 10th graders take). When they listed what frustrated them about the relationship, they noticed that every item focused on the other person. That small realization shifted their focus to what they could control: their own reactions and growth. The project created the space for the insight, and that is Transformational Learning!

 

Who Your Student Is Becoming

In a real class, these six practices work together. A story opens the lesson. A good question starts the discussion. A mentor who knows the student gives feedback that lands, and the learning data shows where to go next. You can see all six described on our curriculum page, and a day-in-the-life of an online student shows where these classes fit into a real week.

Years from now, your student probably won't remember every assignment. They'll remember the mentor who asked what they really thought and waited for the answer, the feedback that showed them they could do better, and the moment they saw themselves a little differently. Those are the experiences that help students become confident, independent thinkers ready to lead.

If you're wondering what learning with our mentors could look like for your student, we'd love to talk. Schedule a Consultation with an Enrollment Advisor to ask your questions and explore which of our schools might be the right fit for your family.